• Switzerland edition

Zurich children's hospital halts circumcisions

Published: 20 Jul 2012 10:34 GMT+02:00 | Print version
Updated: 20 Jul 2012 10:34 GMT+02:00

Zurich University Children’s Hospital has decided to stop performing circumcisions in the wake of a controversial German court decision.

The hospital announced on Thursday that it would cease providing the surgical procedure in non-medical cases while it weighed the legal and ethical concerns.

The moratorium follows a ruling by a regional court in Cologne on June 26th.

The court declared that a doctor performing a circumcision on a four-year-old Muslim boy had compromised the physical integrity of the child.

The decision sparked an angry backlash from Jewish and Muslim groups who claim the ruling amounts to an attack on religious freedom.

On the same day as the Zurich hospital announced its decision, Germany’s lower house of parliament approved a resolution to protect the religious circumcision of infant boys.
 
German Chancellor Angela Merkel’s government also pledged to bring in new legislation to ensure that neither doctors nor families will be criminally charged for carrying out the procedure.

But the Zurich hospital maintains it is concerned about the ethics of surgery over which children are unable to provide their views and for which it may be liable to charges of assault.

Rita Gobet, head of urology, said in a statement issued on the hospital’s website that management decided on the moratorium to allow for a legal assessment and advice from ethics experts on the issue.

The Zurich children's hospital usually performs one circumcision every month or two.

The moratorium does not affect the removal of foreskins for medical reasons.

Your comments about this article:

The comments below have not been moderated in advance and are not produced by The Local unless clearly stated. Readers are responsible for the content of their own comments. Comments that breach our terms and conditions will be removed.

2012-07-26 21:02:11 by Mrs Samar
Salam. First it was wearing the head covering, now circumcisions !! People! welcome Islam in the western society. Instead of blindfully disregarding it, investigate it. Freedom to practice religion should be for all . So if in Islam and in Judaism, circumcision is a practice, let them follow it. No body stops you from christening your babies in muslim countries. So why are you stopping circumcisions ?? “Everyone is entitled to all the rights and freedoms set forth in this Declaration, without distinction of any kind, such as race, color, sex, language, religion, political or other opinion, national or social origin, property, birth or other status. Furthermore, no distinction shall be made on the basis of the political, jurisdictional or international status of the country or territory to which a person belongs, whether it be independent, trust, non-self-governing or under any other limitation of sovereignty”, states Article 2 of United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
2012-08-03 16:12:50 by smeghead
good idea, i mean this cutting edge reporting, slices away at the articale, but joking aside Mrs Samar says that you can christening your babies in muslim countries, I think you are wrong, after living in a Muslim country it is not aloud. as for human rights lark, what about the people who are locked up in prisions waiting for their turn at been stoned, or people in prison acussed of being terrosist's but have not been charged in 10 yrs, that is important, not some out dated idea from way back when people where more simple than they are today, what about syria their human right's bit more important.
2012-08-08 09:24:07 by Misaki85
Belonging to a certain religion does not entitle someone to the right to carve their religion into another person's genitals. Circumcision is a violation of human rights: it is of no medical value, removes thousands of nerve endings, and causes scar tissue. Only the owner of the penis should decide whether or not he wants part of his penis cut off. The child's right to their own body and their own freedom of and from religion trumps parental rights. Not to mention that Islam doesn't have much of a case at all for demanding circumcision on religious grounds, seeing as how the Qu'ran doesn't mention circumcision. Much less require it. All children, male and female, deserve to be protected from genital mutilation.
ADD YOUR COMMENT   (YOU MUST LOG IN OR REGISTER TO MAKE A COMMENT)
Today's headlines
Former Red Cross chief to head Swisspeace
Jakob Kellenberger. Photo: ICRC

Former Red Cross chief to head Swisspeace

Jakob Kellenberger, former Swiss diplomat and ex-president of the International Committee of the Red Cross, is taking over as head of Swisspeace, the Bern-based NGO. READ () »

Richemont brands sale mooted after resignation
Photo: Richemont

Richemont brands sale mooted after resignation

Swiss luxury goods giant Richemont said on Tuesday that a top executive had resigned, amid expectations the group that owns Cartier, Piaget and Montblanc will sell off under-performing brands. READ () »

Report narrows causes of fatal Sierre bus crash
Photo: Sierre cantonal police

Report narrows causes of fatal Sierre bus crash

The crash of a Belgian coach that killed 28 passengers, including 22 children, on a ski trip to Switzerland last year was caused either by a malaise suffered by the driver or by his inattention, an official said on Tuesday. READ () »

Out-of-control Jaguar kills elderly pedestrian
St. Paul's church, near where the fatal accident occurred. Photo: Wikimedia Commons

Out-of-control Jaguar kills elderly pedestrian

An elderly woman is dead after an out-of-control car knocked her down on Monday in the centre of Lucerne, where she was walking. READ () »

Marchers protest judicial 'lapses' in woman's death
Marie, found dead last week after being abducted by a convicted murderer under house arrest. Photo: Vaud cantonal police

Marchers protest judicial 'lapses' in woman's death

More than 250 people took part in a march in Lausanne on Monday afternoon to protest against the judicial system in the wake of the death of Marie, a 19-year-old woman killed last Wednesday after being kidnapped. READ () »

Grasshopper clinches Swiss Cup football title
Grasshoppers celebrate winning the cup for 19th time. Photo: Grasshopper Club Zürich

Grasshopper clinches Swiss Cup football title

In a surprise result, Zurich-based football club Grasshopper beat defending champions FC Basel on penalty kicks on Monday to gain the 19th Swiss Cup victory in its history. READ () »

Swiss lose to Swedes in world ice hockey final
Members of the Swiss team celebrating during earlier win against Sweden. Photo: AFP

Swiss lose to Swedes in world ice hockey final

After going undefeated throughout the world ice hockey championship tournament, Switzerland finally succumbed to home town favorite Sweden in the final, losing 5-1 in Stockholm on Sunday. READ () »

Swiss to face hosts in world hockey tournament

Switzerland will play hosts Sweden in the final of the world ice hockey championships on Sunday after each side registered a 3-0 semi-final victory over the United States and Finland respectively. READ () »

Thieves pinch Swiss jewels from Cannes
US actress Eva Longoria poses on Friday at the 66th edition of the Cannes Film Festival in Cannes. Photo: AFP

Thieves pinch Swiss jewels from Cannes

Jewellery worth more than $1 million made by Swiss luxury watchmaker and jeweller Chopard and due to be loaned to stars walking the red carpet at the Cannes film festival were stolen from a hotel, French police said on Friday. READ () »

Chinese premier set to visit Switzerland
Chinese Premier Li Keqiang. Photo: AFP

Chinese premier set to visit Switzerland

Chinese Premier Li Keqiang embarks this weekend on his first foreign trip since taking office, with a stop in Switzerland on the itinerary and free trade talks between the two countries close to completion. READ () »

Highlights
Furniture Leasing Corporation
Henrik Trygg/imagebank.swede.se
Latest news from The Local in Sweden

More news from Sweden at thelocal.se

Latest news from The Local in Germany

More news from Germany at thelocal.de

Latest news from The Local in France

More news from France at thelocal.fr

Latest news from The Local in Norway

More news from Norway at thelocal.no