Published: 13 Dec 2012 18:23 GMT+01:00 | Print version
Updated: 13 Dec 2012 18:23 GMT+01:00
The lower house of parliament has voted to allow gays in Switzerland to adopt children, but in very limited circumstances, passing the sensitive issue back to the Senate.
With 113 votes in favour and 64 against, the 200-seat house on Thursday opted to allow gays to adopt any biological or adopted children that their partner had before the start of their relationship.
The lower house, or National Council, thus tiptoed in the footsteps of the senate, or State Council, which adopted a far broader measure in March.
Switzerland's largest party, the populist right-wing Swiss People's Party (SVP), had called on the lower house to reject Thursday's motion, insisting children should have a
mother and a father.
"If we accept this Senate motion today, we are opening a Pandora's box," warned SVP's Oskar Freysinger ahead of the vote.
The motion was "radical and goes against nature," agreed Christian Luescher of the Free Democratic Party, which was split down the middle on the issue.
"Nature wants a child to have a father and a mother, not two fathers or two mothers," he insisted.
Other critics in parliament meanwhile said that the change did not go far enough and criticised the chamber for not passing the same motion voted through the upper house of parliament.
That version allowed adoption for all adults, regardless of their lifestyles or marital status.
Socialist Carlos Sommaruga, who voted in favour of Thursday's motion, meanwhile described it as a "first small step" to help children already living with same-sex parents.
He stressed that the current law, which explicitly bans adoption by homosexuals in registered partnerships but not by single gays, was "incoherent" and "leads to distortions and absurd situations."
Cathy Ecoffoy, the co-president of the Swiss association Rainbow Families, also stressed the irony of the current law.
"If you have a God-daughter, for instance, who loses her parents, you are not allowed to adopt her because you are in a partnership," she told AFP.
Although Ecoffoy would have preferred the March motion, she welcomed Thursday's vote as a step in the right direction.
"We enthusiastically hail this vote because it takes into account the reality for children . . . who until now have been raised in an unjust way," she said.
She pointed out that children already living with same-sex couples have no legal rights in relation to their non-biological parent, with for instance no guarantees they can continue living with that person if the biological parent were to die.
Any law change on this issue meanwhile cannot be expected for quite a while.
Thursday's vote means the upper house will now need to vote on the narrower motion and if approved, the government will be asked to draw up a proposal
that will be resubmitted to a new parliamentary vote.
In light of the sensitive nature of the issue, observers say opponents might very well manage to gather the 100,000 signatures needed for it to be put to a national referendum.
Switzerland has since 2005 allowed homosexuals to enter into legally binding registered partnerships, but that law explicitly banned gays in partnerships from adopting.
Steffan Millius grips his sword and makes his way through the throngs of people crowding into Appenzell's central square to take part in Switzerland's famous direct democracy in perhaps its purest form. READ () »
A University of Neuchâtel professor under fire for alleged plagiarism is now facing accusations of falsifying his CV. READ () »
The sailboat of Swiss explorer and adventurer Mike Horn was ordered seized by a Marseille court in a southern French port over a dispute involving a naval architect, according to a media report. READ () »
Geneva cantonal police raided eight erotic massage parlours on Tuesday for an investigation into tax fraud allegedly amounting to several million francs. READ () »
A diamond necklace from Geneva jeweller De Grisogono worth 2.5 million francs was reported stolen from Cannes on Thursday, just days after thieves made off with 1.4 million francs' worth of bling from Chopard, another jeweller from the Swiss city. READ () »
Chinese Premier Li Keqiang sees a looming free-trade deal with Switzerland as a touchstone for Beijing's growing ties with foreign nations, he told a Swiss newspaper on Thursday ahead of a landmark visit to Europe. READ () »
Whether you have ever or never visited the Netherlands, the country that crowned a new monarch this year is also celebrating a wealth of special jubilees in its popular capital. Here’s the lowdown on why Amsterdam is the place to be in 2013. READ () »
After a wetter than usual start to spring, Switzerland is bracing for a return to wintry conditions and snow in some locations over the next few days. READ () »
Switzerland, currently in the process of restituting assets to several former autocratic countries, is working on a new law aimed at simplifying the process of freezing and unblocking such funds, the government said on Wednesday. READ () »
A project backed by two of Switzerland’s wealthiest men to create a Geneva biotech centre is back on track after German pharma company Merck agreed to sell its sprawling complex in the Swiss city. READ () »