• Switzerland's news in English
 
app_header_v3

American couple lock horns with Swiss farmer over ‘cattle cruelty’

Morven McLean · 15 Jan 2013, 18:38

Published: 15 Jan 2013 18:38 GMT+01:00

They have gathered detailed evidence, which they say proves that animal welfare laws are being violated. The Swiss have toughened regulations to protect animals from mistreatment but it's too late as far as Bryant and Diana Dorsch are concerned. The Dorsches, from Kreuzlingen in the canton of Thurgau, campaigned for over a year to save a cow and her calf suffering apparent neglect and mistreatment. They wanted to buy the two animals and move them to a sanctuary.

Despite being offered more than the slaughter price, the farmer went ahead and had the animals butchered at the end of last year. The Dorsches took over 3,000 photographs and recorded around 50 hours of video footage of the alleged ill treatment of cattle on the farm neighbouring their home between April 2010 and October last year.

Cow crusade

After moving next to the farm  with her new husband in April 2010, Diana Dorsch developed a relationship with one  of the animals in the herd of 60 or so cattle, “Baby” — a black and white calf. Concerned at the filthy state of the animals, she tried to persuade the farmer to improve their conditions. 


But little changed and in the two years that followed the Dorsches say they reported many violations of animal protection ordinances to the canton of Thurgau veterinary office. These violations included allowing the animals to lie in their own filth and failing to provide water.

The Dorsches gathered fresh grass for the cows during the winter months when they were confined to the barn, and every time they were led out to pasture fed them apples and carrots. Meantime, Baby gave birth to a calf of her own. Learning that the farmland was to be sold for the construction of apartments, Diana Dorsch asked to buy Baby and her calf from the farmer but he refused to sell.

She last saw the cow and calf on October 11th last year. A day later, the two were taken away for slaughter along with three other cows. “I can’t tell you how shocked I was,” recalls Dorsch, still traumatised by what happened.

The farmer was unavailable for comment, but in a statement to the animal protection group VgT, his wife accuses Diana Dorsch of taking “revenge” on them, and says the “feeding of bags of carrots and apples to the animals caused them digestive problems”.

Legal framework

Dr Paul Witzig, head of the Thurgau cantonal veterinary office, confirms that he handled the abuse allegations but says that for reasons of confidentiality he cannot comment on what action was taken.

The animal protection law was revised in 2008, clarifying the rules on keeping cattle. After a transition period certain provisions will come into force from September 1st this year.

These federal regulations state that the surface where cattle are kept must always be clean. The animals should also be properly fed and watered. “Calves must be able to drink water at all times,” the law says. “Cattle need water at least twice a day.”

The Federal Veterinary Office says there are no nationwide statistics on reported cases of mistreatment of farm animals. But figures from 2011 show legal proceedings were brought in 211 cases for mistreatment of cattle, up from 154 cases the year before.

“Farmers generally respect the rules as they know that violations can soon become costly, and also because they know that they can make money by looking after their animals well,” Witzig says.

The Thurgau veterinary official says two to three dozen reports of violations of the law involving cattle are reported in the canton annually, a figure that has remained constant for a number of years. But the type of infringement being reported has changed. The stalls now being built mean it is less common for cattle to be tied up and have their movement restricted. However, there are more cases of cattle in a dirty condition because the tendency towards larger herds means less care is given to individual animals.

“The farmers know the rules, and the rules are clear,” Witzig says. “But violations still take place, just as there are always people who drive too fast. The reasons are usually too much work, lack of investment or no-one to take over the farm, and financial and social problems.”

While cattle are to be better protected by the law, it remains legal for Swiss to eat cats and dogs. Diana Dorsch and her husband hope to end that anomaly. They want to raise the required 100,000 signatures to bring a popular initiative against the consumption of dog and cat meat in Switzerland.

Morven McLean (news@thelocal.ch)

Your comments about this article

2013-02-04 14:39:53 by bellsucks
Ban Yanks seems like a solution.
Today's headlines
Geneva advises teachers on religion in school
File photo: C Carlstead

The secular canton of Geneva has issued guidelines for teachers on how to deal with religious issues in the classroom.

All you need to know about Switzerland’s strangest sports
Swiss wrestling is the main event at the Eidgenössische. Photo: Ulrich Ackermann/Swiss Tourism

The Local takes a closer look at the unique Swiss sports that are the highlight of the Fédérale, or Eidgenössische, festival this weekend.

Basel woman tied up and robbed in own home
Basel city. File photo: Michelle Kinsey Bruns

The victim was attacked by three burglars in her home in broad daylight.

Swiss sports court upholds Russia ban from Paralympics
Head of Russia's Paralympic Committee Vladimir Lukin. Photo: Yuri Kadobnov/AFP

Russia has lost an appeal against a suspension issued over a vast, state-run doping programme.

Swiss Post trials robot parcel deliveries in Bern
The robots are designed to carry out local deliveries autonomously. Photo: Starship

Robots will be seen on the streets of the Swiss capital next month.

 Mia and Noah are top Swiss baby names – again
File photo: Robert Valencia

Name choices have varied little over the past few years.

Valais battles to save famous apricots from fruit fly
Apricots are a symbol of the Valais. Photo: Valais Tourism

The suzukii fruit fly has destroyed up to 20 percent of this year’s luizet apricots.

US approves Chinese mega deal with Swiss company
The chairmans of ChemChina and Syngenta met in February to discuss the deal. Photo: Michael Buholzer/AFP

ChemChina's takeover of Syngenta would be by far the biggest-ever overseas acquisition by a Chinese firm.

Germany bolsters Swiss border against refugees
Ther Swiss-German border at Kreuzlingen. Photo: Fabrice Coffrini/AFP

The number of refugees trying to enter Germany through Switzerland has risen significantly in 2016.

Rio 2016
In pictures: final day success takes Swiss to seven medals
Nino Schurter wins Switzerland's third gold of Rio 2016. Photo: Pascal Guyot/AFP

Nino Schurter takes mountain biking gold on the last day of competition.

Sponsored Article
Why expats choose international health insurance
Photo: AFP
Politics
Survey: Swiss optimistic about Brexit effect
Sponsored Article
Why you should attend an international job fair
Photo: Neil Heritage/Endeavour Fund
Features
Amputee's Matterhorn trek 'makes it more possible' for others
Photo: EPFL
International
Switzerland tops global innovation table – again
Sponsored Article
Five things Americans should know about voting abroad
Photo: Vasily Cotovanu
National
Asylum centre plans shelved after Swiss village protests
Sponsored Article
Jordan: where history meets adventure
Photo: The Local
Politics
Neuchâtel looks to boost rights for foreigners
Photo: AFP
Sport
In pictures: final day success takes Swiss to seven medals
Photo: AFP
National
Experts debate rail security following Swiss train attack
Sponsored Article
Why expats choose international health insurance
File photo: AFP
Sport
Two basejumpers die in Lauterbrunnen accidents
Sponsored Article
Why you should attend an international job fair
Photo: AFP
International
Amnesty fears for child migrants at Italian border
Photo: AXA Winterthur
National
Report: Geneva is Swiss capital of car theft
Sponsored Article
Jordan Pass: your ticket to the experience of a lifetime
Photo: Dani Pozo/AFP
National
Top tips for watching the meteor shower in Switzerland
Sponsored Article
Life in Jordan: 'Undiscovered treasure'
File photo: Andrew Turner
Technology
Swiss start-up to offer drone service to farmers
Photo: Beat Strasser
National
British quadruple amputee summits Matterhorn
Photo: Judit Klein
National
Switzerland sees rise in child victims of forced marriage
Photo: Michael Schlick/OS Muhr
National
Swiss hiker in Austria rescued after sending SOS to America
Photo: Chris Murphy
Features
14 mistakes foreigners make on moving to Switzerland
Photo: AFP
Lifestyle
Swiss resort unveils huge ‘natural’ fresco on mountain
Photo: C Sonderegger/Swiss Tourism
National
Five great Swiss traditions all expats should try
Photo: AFP
National
Confirmed cases of Zika virus soar in Switzerland
Photo: eGuide Travel
National
Prison for woman who faked Swiss airport bomb threat
Photo: AFP
Technology
Swiss solar plane completes epic round-the-world trip
File photo: Chase Elliott Clark
Lifestyle
Study: a fifth of Swiss spy on neighbours
Photo: Katwarn.de
National
Switzerland mulls alarm text message service
4,697
jobs available