• Switzerland edition

Photo credit: Lawrence Sawyer

Why Swiss gun love is coming under fire

Published: 05 Jan 2012 15:26 GMT+1
Updated: 03 Jan 2012 15:29 GMT+1
Online: http://www.thelocal.ch/2215/20120105/

Almost two centuries have passed since Switzerland last fought in a war, yet the country's gun ownership rate remains the highest in Europe. After a series of gun-related killings at the end of last year, The Local's Meritxell Mir looks at what's being done to get fingers off triggers.

Every year, more than 300 people die in Switzerland in gun-related incidents. In many ways, the figure is quite low, when one considers the country has about 2.5 million weapons in private hands — giving it the highest per capita rate of gun ownership in Europe, and the fourth highest in the world.

In the last two months of 2011, however, shots rang out with alarming frequency in a country where around 30 percent of all households keep guns and rifles in their cabinets.

In early November, a 23-year-old man killed his girlfriend using his army assault rifle in the village of Saint-Leonard. The vicious crime sparked fervent debate about the lax monitoring of repeat offenders.

After that, the tragic tales began to tumble in thick and fast: Victim shot dead by stranger at Geneva shopping centre; Young man killed in accidental shooting; Evicted tenant kills neighbour with hunting rifle.

But in a country that cherishes its centuries-old firearms tradition, gun control is a touchy subject.

“The Swiss have this romantic idea of their culture, in the sense that they have to have the means to protect their independence, and everyone is like a citizen soldier,” explains Philip Jaffé, a Geneva-based psychologist who often works with the police in forensic crime investigations.

In the last 15 years, cantonal and federal firearms laws have increasingly been amended to prevent misuse.

But advocates of a gun-free Switzerland have also suffered setbacks, most recently in February 2011, when the Swiss voted on an anti-gun initiative backed by a coalition of 70 organisations.

The proposal sought to create a national registry of weapons, ban the most dangerous firearms (such as automatic and pump-action models), and force militia soldiers to leave their army weapons at the barracks. The ‘Stop Gun Violence’ initiative was defeated, with 56.3 percent voting ’No’.

However, the recent spate of killings has prompted Swiss politicians to rekindle the gun debate, and a parliamentary security commission is currently working on potential changes to the law.

“Every death is one too many, and every weapon that is lying around, whether controlled or not, is a potential danger,” says Christophe Barbey, political secretary of the Group for a Switzerland without Weapons (GSoA).

“How many deaths do we need before we change things,” he asks.

Aside from hunters and collectors, Switzerland also has more than 150,000 active rifle club members, most of whom live in rural regions. The country hosts the world’s largest shooting event once a year.

But experts agree that a surplus of army-issue guns is the most pressing problem, and many feel they should be kept in barracks. Every adult male must complete 260 days of military service before the age of 34, during which period he keeps his pistol or assault rifle at home.

“There is no strategic necessity anymore for soldiers to keep their weapons at home”, says Barbey. “Those times are over,” he adds.

After they are discharged, soldiers are entitled to keep the weapon for the rest of their lives for a small fee. Some 1.5 million of the estimated 2.5 million weapons in the country belong to, or have belonged to, the army.

All of the experts consulted for this article say Switzerland should institute a national gun register to replace the 26 cantonal registers.

The head of the Swiss Agency for Crime Prevention, Martin Boess, also stresses the need for improved information exchange procedures between social services, police, the judiciary, and the army. This would enable the authorities “to see what kind of people are in possession of weapons.”

The 23-year-old man who killed his girlfriend in Saint-Leonard had previous convictions for property damage and making threats. The 47-year-old man who killed his neighbour had also killed his girlfriend’s lover in the 1990s. Both had licensed weapons at home.

But while homicides and murders continue to make headlines, the high numbers of gun-related suicides are much less widely discussed. Only when the victims are high-ranking public figures do suicides come to the fore, as was the case in late November when the vice-president of the Zug cantonal parliament, Martin B. Lehman, shot himself at his holiday home in Ticino. 

His case was by no means an isolated one. According to Stop Suicide, three suicides take place every day in Switzerland, making for a total of around 1,300 suicides each year. Guns rank second, after hanging, as the most common method, with firearms accounting for a quarter of all cases. This figure rises to 40 percent in cantons like Basel, Thurgau and Zug, according to a 2010 study.

Stop Suicide and similar organisations have been fighting for years for tighter firearms regulations, aware that international studies show a strong correlation between gun availability and suicide.

“The cantons with the highest suicide rates are Uri, Obwalden, Nidwalden and Schwyz, and they also have the highest gun possession rate,” says Anne-Marie Trabichet, a coordinator at Stop Suicide.

In the 1980s, when Canada changed its laws and gun ownership dropped from from 31 to 19 percent, the number of suicides involving guns fell in tandem, from 32 percent to 19 percent.

In 1997, Austria changed its laws to restrict access to guns. Between 1998 and 2005, the country saw an annual reduction of five percent in suicide cases.

“This proves that suicide methods are not transmissible because if they were, the suicide rate would remain and there would be an increase in other ways to kill oneself,” she explains.

Four times more people die from suicide than from road accidents every year in Switzerland. Yet, “suicides are a big taboo,” says Trabichet, who explains that most people are not aware of the extent of the problem and don't think it’s the government’s duty to combat it.

The grey market is also a problem. In 1999, a federal law established that sales of weapons among individuals did not have to be registered. In 2008, the Federal Council amended its decision, but a lot of weapons got lost along the way.

In a recent interview with La Tribune de Genève, the head of the Weapons Service of the Geneva police, Bernard Bersier, said that during those nine years, the authorities lost track of between 20,000 and 25,000 weapons.

Currently, the anonymous sale of weapons is forbidden, but it is almost impossible to monitor all transactions. Police only act when someone reports abuse or suspicion.

In the meantime, cantonal police, judicial authorities and the army have created a working group to set out ways of sharing information about criminal investigations involving soldiers. The army is also working on new measures to reduce the risks related to the abuse of army-issue weapons.

“Times are changing very rapidly and this [romantic Swiss gun] mentality cannot remain without a lot of sad stories taking place,” says psychologist Jaffé.

Meritxell Mir (news@thelocal.ch)

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Fark It! Digg This  Share everywhere
Send to a friend Printable version Twitter This

Your comments about this article:

The comments below have not been moderated in advance and are not produced by The Local unless clearly stated. Readers are responsible for the content of their own comments. Comments that breach our terms and conditions will be removed.

05 Jan 2012 16:27 GMT+1 by Varsil
In Canada, registering guns did reduce suicides by shooting. Unfortunately, suicides by hanging went up exactly as much as suicides by shooting went down, for zero net change in suicides. We've also seen a rise in home invasion robberies, where armed men break into occupied homes, typically targetting the homeowner for sudden violence to disable them before forcing the homeowner to show them where the valuables are. They can to this with impunity, as the laws here require that firearms be locked away. Think very hard before you give up your traditions, Switzerland. Many of us here in Canada, which is being cited as a good example, envy you instead.
05 Jan 2012 17:33 GMT+1 by Global Macro
Australia experienced similar bad result when they passed laws against gun ownership. Home invasions rose. The axioms that you frequently hear are true. "When guns are outlawed, only the outlaws will have guns." "Guns do not kill people. Bad people kill people." Protect freedom of Swiss to own guns; defeat the gun laws.
06 Jan 2012 23:26 GMT+1 by nimzo
The following study from criminologist of Universt. de montréal shows a diminution of 5-10% of the homicides following the introduction of the gun control law. ==== L'EFFET DES LOIS EN MATIÈRE DE CONTRÔLE DES ARMES À FEU SUR LES HOMICIDES AU CANADA, 1974-2004 Étienne Blais, Ph.D. Professeur, École de criminologie, Université de Montréal Marie-Pier Gagné, M.Sc. et Isabelle Linteau http://www.ccja-acjp.ca/fr/rcc2/rcc53r1.html
07 Jan 2012 01:18 GMT+1 by nimzo
English abstract of the article in my previous message. Yes gun control saves lives. http://www.ccja-acjp.ca/en/cjc2/cjc53a1.html nimzo from Canada
08 Jan 2012 16:14 GMT+1 by Global Macro
This is a highly charged political issue. Most statistical analyses are ideologically motivated, so readers should approach these analyses very skeptically. In fact, the cities with the highest gun control laws also have the highest murder rates. Here are two articles that support a contrary view to those expressed above. The statistical evidence is inconclusive at best; in fact, it may be that stricter gun control laws have an adverse result on crime. http://articles.baltimoresun.com/2011-01-20/news/bs-ed-smith-20110120_1_gun-ownership-gun-issue-gun-control-laws http://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2008/02/guns_save_lives.html
19 Jan 2012 05:59 GMT+1 by Jeff10
In the US, the jurisdictions with the highest gun ownership have the lowest crime rates. An armed society is a polite society. Witness Switzerland. As for the 47-year-old man, what the heck was he doing out of prison after murdering another person in the 1990's? Rather than gun control laws, the Swiss should consider dropping out of the EU and bringing back capital punishment. It's a deterrent that's 100% effective. Consider this: No excecuted murderer has ever committed another murder.
24 Jan 2012 16:02 GMT+1 by roaringchicken83
The cleverest argument against gun control that I've heard that refutes the 'just look at the instances of crimes with firearms' argument for gun control is this: in the U.S., about 600 people die every year as the result of complications derived from drinking milk, another 850 die as the result of complications derived from eating peanuts. Does this mean consumption of milk and peanuts should be outlawed or strictly controlled? After all, milk and peanuts kill people.... I agree -- hang on to your current gun laws, Switzerland. There is no legitimate argument for changing them.
01 Mar 2012 14:47 GMT+1 by n230099
"When no one knows who is armed...everyone is." Historically, when governments know where the guns are and who has them things tend to go bad in a hurry.
08 Mar 2012 01:16 GMT+1 by Avidror
@ Jeff10 In fact, Switzerland is not in the European Union. And the capital punishment doesn't decrease crime; the United States have many more crimes per capita than any other First World country and is one of the few developed democracies which still maintain the death penalty. @ roaringchicken83 Peanuts and milk are food, guns are not; food is necessary in the hands of citizens, guns are not. @ n230099 Historically, you're wrong. The U.S., Switzerland, Canada and Finland, for example, are free countries with high gun possession rates. But Yemen is also a country whose citizens are well armed. Is Yemen a free country? No, it isn't. It's a dictatorship. And guns are much more restricted in Spain, Germany or Japan, which are democracies. Non-restrictive gun laws are not the main historical cause behind freedom and democracy.
22 Mar 2012 21:23 GMT+1 by Jeff10
@avidror: In the US, the crime rate for non-hispanic whites is lower than the crime rate for Japan, yet this group has the highest legal gun ownership in the US. Capital punishment does decrease crime. No executed murderer has ever committed another murder. Other than that irrebuttable fact, there are dozens of studies confirming that longer incarceration and capital punishment reduce crime. All islame countries are bloody. In Yemen and most other islame countries, you're as likely to be killed by a bomb as by a fire arm.
28 Mar 2012 13:58 GMT+1 by Oliver Jones
If you allow gun ownership, you will have criminals armed with guns. If you disallow gun ownership, you will still have criminals armed with guns. That's a simple fact of life: Organised criminals will always find a way to arm themselves. If you disarm a population, you give the criminals more power, not less - and you give criminals less reason to be careful about what crimes they commit - and where they commit them. Not every person in this universe is kind, compassionate or considerate. But banning firearms because they can be used to kill people is about as useful as banning pillows because they have been used to suffocate people. Both pillows and firearms can be used for evil purposes - but both bring innumerable advantages - a good night's sleep in the case of the former, and the knowledge that any criminal will think twice before breaking into a home that is likely to have a readily-available firearm turned on them. Readily-available firearms are an excellent deterrent - and this is something that deserves considerable thought. If you remove the prospect that a criminal may lose his/her life in the process of breaking and entering, you will see more breaking and entering as a direct consequence. Criminals aren't stupid - they might have less issues with their conscience than the rest of us, but they are pretty good at assessing risk versus reward. As for suicides, someone in that state of mind will choose to end their life with whatever means is available to them. If they cannot use a gun, they will use something else. Various evidence already exists that supports this. Besides, removing guns does not solve the state of mind that leads to suicide - early diagnosis and psychological treatment is what you need for that.
ADD YOUR COMMENT   (YOU MUST LOG IN OR REGISTER TO MAKE A COMMENT)
Today's headlines

Photo credit: PHOTOPRESS/Schweiz Tourismus/Andrea Badrutt

Rhine swimmer cuts short 'impossible' quest

Ernst Bromeis, the Swiss swimmer who set out to swim the length of the Rhine, has given up his quest after about 400 kilometres due to health concerns. READ »
COMMENT »


Photo credit: Sotheby's

Historic diamond sells for $9.7 million in Geneva

A centuries-old diamond passed down through generations of European royalty fetched nine million francs ($9.7 million) at auction in Geneva on Tuesday. READ »


Photo credit: Swiss parliament, Marcin Wichary

Anti-German rant 'worse than euro crisis'

The Swiss tourist trade is continuing to suffer the ill effects of a far-right politician's claim there are too many Germans in Switzerland. READ (3 comments) »
COMMENT »


Photo credit: Brunel University

Bolt to race in Zurich Diamond League

Double Olympic sprint champion Usain Bolt will race in the Zurich leg of the Diamond League on August 30th, organizers announced on Monday. READ »
COMMENT »

Lucerne double shooter killed himself: police

A 33-year-old Kosovar man who seriously injured his wife and her mother in a shooting incident last week died from self-inflicted injuries, and not from a shot fired by his wife's brother, according to media reports.    READ »
COMMENT »

Swiss lawyer wanted in US family fraud case

A British lawyer has been charged and a Swiss lawyer is wanted for questioning by the US tax authorities for allegedly helping a well-known American family to hide unpaid taxes in Swiss bank accounts. READ »
COMMENT »

Swiss army to buy new bicycles -- with gears

Forget the Swiss army knife, Swiss soldiers will soon be issued with the latest in two-wheel technology -- brand new bicycles to keep the men fit on mountain roads. READ »
COMMENT »


Photo credit: Gage Skidmore (File)

Ex-White House hopeful in Swiss passport U-turn

Former White House hopeful Michele Bachmann said on Thursday she has decided to withdraw from having Swiss nationality as well as a US passport, because, she proclaimed: "I am a proud American citizen." READ (2 comments) »
COMMENT »

More Society
  • King of kitsch Jeff Koons brings 'empty' art to Basel (2 comments) »
  • Introducing... Michelle Hunziker (2 comments) »
  • Why I'm swimming the length of the Rhine (2 comments) »
  • Introducing... Doris Leuthard (2 comments) »
  • How I got hot and native in a Swiss sauna (2 comments) »
  • Ten great reasons to travel this summer (2 comments) »
  • The ten best railway stations in Europe (2 comments) »
  • Gadget geeks descend on Geneva (2 comments) »
  • Models don choc frocks for tasty Zurich fashion show (2 comments) »
  • Moving made easy: Top tips for your international move (2 comments) »
  • Highlights
    Photo: Contiki Holidays
    Photo: Mobilitas
    Photo: Eurail
    Photo: stock
    Latest news from The Local in Sweden

    More news from Sweden at thelocal.se

    Latest news from The Local in Germany

    More news from Germany at thelocal.de

    Latest news from The Local in France

    More news from France at thelocal.fr

    Latest news from The Local in Norway

    More news from Norway at thelocal.no

    Sponsored links
    Learn French in Switzerland at our renowned French school on the Swiss Riviera: ESL School Montreux – booking made easy with ESL – Séjours linguistiques