• Switzerland's news in English
A guaranteed income: why the Swiss said no
File photo: Fabrice Coffrini/AFP

A guaranteed income: why the Swiss said no

The Local · 6 Jun 2016, 11:33

Published: 06 Jun 2016 11:33 GMT+02:00

Facebook Twitter Google+ reddit

Why? The vagueness of the proposal, a lack of detail over its financing and fear of the unknown were among the reasons reported in the press on Monday.

The idea of receiving a guaranteed monthly income of 2,500 francs, even if you don’t work, may seem a utopia to many.

But in a country where “economic realism is a cardinal virtue”, according to L’Hebdo, its rejection is not so surprising.

“Utopia did not convince,” said the magazine, reminding readers that the conservative Swiss have previously rejected proposals for more holiday, a minimum wage and limitations on the salaries of heads of companies.

The main error of yes campaigners was lack of clarity over how it would be financed, it said.

“The figure of 2,500 francs supposed to be the monthly allowance for each resident, far from arousing desire, posed the question: from whose pockets will it be sought?”  

Speaking to the Tribune de Genève, PLR councillor Laurent Wehrli agreed.

“The project was masterfully vague and put the Swiss economy in danger. The people understood that,” he said.

For supporters of a UBI, the principle was, as expected, simply too large for voters to swallow at this point in time.

“Citizens are scared of the implications and the unknown factors implementing it could bring,” Lisa Mazzone of the Green party – the only major party to support the initiative – told the Tribune.

Speaking to The Local , Gabriel Barta of the Basic Income Earth Network (BIEN) in Switzerland said: “The conservative Swiss could not accept such a thoroughgoing societal change when, in a country whose prosperity has not yet visibly deteriorated, they did not understand the necessity for it.

“While we cannot guarantee that society will not be turned upside down, the necessity for a UBI will become evident with time. It took four popular votes and 50 years to approve the AVS (old-age pension).”

As for the government, the defeat of the UBI was a vote of confidence for the current welfare system.

Announcing the results in a press conference the Swiss minister for home affairs, Alain Berset, said: “The results show that the public are happy with the social system we have in place, that the system works well, that we should continue to develop it.... collectivism helps and supports those who need it.”

Despite being rejected by 76.9 percent of the voting public overall, the UBI did garner pockets of support.

Among them, two communes in the Jura voted in favour of the initiative, as did 54.6 percent of voters in the Pâquis area of Geneva, said the Tribune.

At cantonal level the cantons of Basel-Ville and the Jura achieved the highest levels of support, with around 36 percent voting in favour. Over 30 percent of voters in Geneva and Neuchâtel also voted for a UBI.

Story continues below…

“The rejection was expected, even if I was hoping for 40 percent overall,” BIEN's Barta told The Local.

“The main result is there, however: everyone now knows of a potential solution to problems whose seriousness is generally recognized.

“The passionate discussions generated by a proposal with absolutely no institutions or organizations behind it, and the fact that one voter in four is already in favour, will ensure that it stays near the top of the priority list.”

Indeed, despite the large overall rejection, there’s no doubt that the vote provoked a discussion on the subject that is unlikely to go away.

The commune of Lausanne has already agreed to launch a study about the feasibility of implementing a UBI in the city, and other regions could follow suit.

“Everyone feels that the traditional state welfare model has limits,” wrote L’Hebdo. “And even if it remains solid and well managed in Switzerland, the subject is likely to be re-examined more and more.”

The results of our own poll, conducted on Friday, were much closer, with 49 percent of readers rejecting the idea of a UBI against 46 percent approving it.

For more news from Switzerland, join us on Facebook and Twitter.

The Local (news@thelocal.ch)

Facebook Twitter Google+ reddit

Your comments about this article

Today's headlines
Presented by MoneyPark
How to get a mortgage in Switzerland
Houses in Zürich. Photo: Pixabay.

Ready to buy? Here’s what you need to know as an expat about Swiss regulations, how to finance your purchase, and why you should use a broker.

Autumn in Switzerland: ten stunning Instagram photos
Photo: Swiss Tourism/Jan Geerk

Switzerland is beautiful in all seasons, but as these photos show, autumn is a special time in the alpine country.

Report: Swiss progress slows on gender equality
File photo: David Soulivet

Globally, it will take 170 years to achieve gender equality, according to the World Economic Forum.

Brothers go to court to stop suicide of sibling
File photo: Lisa Edmonds

Two men have filed a legal bid to prevent the Swiss assisted suicide association Exit from helping their older brother to kill himself.

Wawrinka snubs past form to reach Basel second round
Wawrinka beat local wildcard Marco Chiudinelli. Photo: Fabrice Coffrini/AFP

US Open champion Stan Wawrinka has reached the second round in Basel after going out in the first round for the past four years.

Villagers asked to help fund bridge renovations
The bridge links the two villages of Veltheim (pictured) and Holderbank. Photo: Lutz Fischer-Lamprecht

The crowdfunding campaign by the two communes is the first of its kind in Switzerland.

Police discover body buried in Orbe house
File photo: Bas Leenders

Police have opened an investigation after finding a body buried in a house in Orbe, in the canton of Vaud, on Saturday.

Valais shaken by 4.2 magnitude earthquake
The earthquake hit in the canton of Valais near Sierre. Photo: Alain Rouiller

It's the biggest earthquake to hit the country for two years.

Swiss Indoors kicks off without champ Federer
Federer celebrates with ball girls and boys after winning the event in 2015. Photo: Harold Cunningham/Pool/AFP

Stan Wawrinka is top seed as injured Federer sits it out.

IOC hires Russian doping whistleblower as consultant
IOC President Thomas Bach confirmed the news. File photo: Fabrice Coffrini/AFP

The International Olympic Committee (IOC) has hired Vitaly Stepanov as a consultant and is helping his runner wife Yuliya.

Photo: Unterirdisch Ueberleben
Inside Switzerland’s largest nuclear bunker – 40 years on
Sponsored Article
Last chance to vote absentee in the US elections
Photo: The Local
Ticino firefighters rescue cow from swimming pool
Photo: Antoni Da Campo
Vegan wins battle to be accepted by Swiss army
Photo: Swiss Tourism
Ten Swiss ski resorts named most expensive in Europe
Photo: Randy Kashka
Swiss women will ‘work for free’ for the rest of year
Photo: Swiss Tourism
Montreux throws hat in Olympic rings
Photo: Swiss Tourism
Seven things you’ll miss about Switzerland if you leave
Photo: Richard Juilliard/AFP
Man makes Geneva airport bomb threat ‘for a joke’
Photo: AFP
Solar Impulse team reveals plans for unmanned plane
File photo: Martin Abegglen
Swiss to vote on passport rules for 3rd gen foreigners
Photo: AFP
Swiss wingsuit hotspot Lauterbrunnen won’t impose ban
Photo: Swiss Tourism
Six reasons Switzerland isn’t as boring as you might think
Photo: Swiss Tourism
Report: Switzerland one of world’s best places for girls
Photo: The Local
Thief returns Swiss cow bells worth thousands
File photo: Wikimedia Commons
One in three rapists isn’t locked up: statistics
Photo: activistin.ch
Tampon-tax protest turns Zurich fountains red
Photo: AFP
Geneva police to lift ban on bearded officers
Photo: Marcel Gillieron/AFP
Suicide chef’s restaurant keeps Michelin stars
Photo: Lara de Salis
11 things the Swiss get tired of hearing abroad
Photo:  Ivo Scholz/Swiss-image.ch
Survey: expats in Switzerland have money but few friends
Photo: AFP
Swiss press criticize Bern’s 'capitulation' on immigration
Photo: Jura Trois Lacs tourism
German ex-policeman is Swiss city’s new hermit
Photo: Dmitry A. Mottl
Ticino votes to favour local workers over foreigners
jobs available