SHARE
COPY LINK
For members

WEATHER

UPDATE: How Switzerland’s flood planning helped it avoid disaster

Despite geographical proximity and similar topography, Switzerland suffered less damage from recent floods than its northern neighbour. This is why.

UPDATE: How Switzerland's flood planning helped it avoid disaster
A woman walks past a car in a flooded waterway in the Swiss town of Lyss, near Bern, in 2007. Unlike the 2005 and 2007 floods, Switzerland was spared the wrath of the 2021 floods. Photo: FABRICE COFFRINI / AFP

After days of unrelenting torrential rain over the past two weeks, water levels in many Swiss lakes and rivers are slowly dropping.

In the the worst flooding in more than a decade, banks on Lake Zurich broke, while levels on Lakes Lucerne, Biel and Thun rose dangerously high.

READ MORE: Weather update: Lake Zurich bursts banks, Lucerne preparing for flooding

But even though some areas of the country were flooded, the damage was far less significant than during the Swiss floods of 2005 and 2007. 

In 2021, Switzerland suffered no weather-related casualties — unlike western Germany, where at least 175 people were found dead as of July 29th. 

Dozens of people also died in Belgium, bringing the total in Western Europe to over 200. 

As both Germany and Switzerland have similar topography experienced similar weather, why was Switzerland affected less than its neighbour?

Why did Switzerland escape the worst of the floods?

Despite some amateur weathermen and women pointing out that Switzerland is in the alps and is therefore upstream, things are a little more complicated than that. 

Anyone who’s lived in Switzerland for more than a couple of years would know how prevalent flooding can be. 

The major reasons for Switzerland’s success was a combination of flood preparation – and sheer luck with the weather. 

Experts say the intensity of rain and the volume of water dumped on both nations made a huge difference.

Switzerland has spent heavily in recent years – and in particular since 2005 – to protect from catastrophic flooding events. 

Despite fields, cellars, basements and train stations being under water, “flood protection has proven itself”, Adrian Schertenleib, head of the flood protection section at the Federal Office for the Environment, told 20 Minutes

A major part of that was the strategic draining of the lakes. 

“After the heavy rainfall from June 20th, the way the population was alerted worked perfectly. From July 7th, when the rain was so prolonged, the regulation of the lakes – for example at Lake Thun or the three Jura lakes – worked very well.

“And most importantly there were no injuries.”

READ MORE: Switzerland drains lakes ahead of predicted weekend rainfall

Schertenleib said Switzerland had accounted for the risks “through the optimal combination of measures: structural-technical, spatial planning, organisational, but also biological.”

Andri Bryner, a trained hydrologist, told 20 Minutes that Switzerland had successfully sought to “build with nature, rather than against it”. 

Giving the example of the Suhre in Aargau and Lucerne, Bryner pointed out how Switzerland adopted an innovative flood prevention method which focused on allowing the river more space in case of floods rather than building barriers. 

“If water is directed through a narrow channel, then it flows faster, has more power and rises higher. If the channel is wider, the water will flow more slowly and rise less,” he said.

“That means: dams or walls have to be less high and less strong and it still works.”

The grassed area where the Aare, Reuss and Limmat rivers meet had been an agricultural area which was regularly flooded, with crops continually failing in the region. 

Bryner said rather than attempting to divert the water around or find other means to stop the flow, the land had been converted to grazing land for cattle. 

Another important factor was simply that Switzerland experienced less rainfall than Germany. 

Switzerland’s Tages Anzeiger noted that the situations in Switzerland and Germany were less comparable, with Switzerland’s flood disaster of 2005 closer to what Germany has experienced in the past two weeks. 

“In Switzerland, the cumulative amount of water over the last two days of rain was 50 to 70 millimetres, while in Germany about 160 millimetres fell over the same period —two to three times more”, hydraulic engineer Philippe Heller told RTS public broadcaster.

Levels similar to those in western Germany were measured in Ticino, which was lashed by 200 millimetres of rain.

However, this kind of precipitation is more common on the southern side of the Alps because of the region’s proximity to the Mediterranean, according to Yves Karrer from the Federal Office of  Meteorology and Climatology.

“The natural rivers are adapted to such quantities. In Germany, on the other hand, it was probably the event of the century”, he said in an interview with Tages-Anzeiger.

In 2005, floods in Switzerland caused major damage. Photo by BRUNO FERRANDEZ / AFP

“The fact that the damage is much smaller now than it was then is a consequence of the measures taken. The federal government and the cantons have invested 4.5 billion francs in flood protection since the 2005 floods”.

READ MORE: Climate change: Glacial melt in Switzerland has created 1,000 new lakes

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.
For members

WEATHER

‘Don’t sleep naked’: How to get a good night’s sleep in a Swiss heatwave

As temperatures climb again, many people may struggle to get a good night's sleep in Switzerland. Here are some expert tips to help you even when it's sweltering hot.

‘Don’t sleep naked’: How to get a good night’s sleep in a Swiss heatwave

Switzerland’s summers tend to get hotter and this season has seen its share of heatwaves, bringing temperatures closer to 40C and making it almost impossible to sleep.

This could mean trouble for residents of a country better prepared to bear the cold weather than the extreme heat.

The Swiss Federal Office of Public Health (FOPH) has three ‘golden rules’ for how to make it through heatwaves; avoid exercise during the hottest part of the day, keep the heat out of your house however you can, drink and eat smart (fresh foods and lots of water).

With night temperatures in some regions above 20C, Swiss residents will also need some help getting through the night.

Here are a few tips to keep cool overnight and enjoy better sleep despite the heat of the night.

Don’t sleep naked

It’s tempting to ditch the PJs when it’s this warm overnight. But sleep experts say this is a mistake, as any moisture from sweat accumulates on your body.

Cotton pyjamas and cotton sheets are very effective in absorbing and removing sweat from your body.

Give a little help to your internal clock

Many people think that it is only the extreme heat in summer making your sleep seem a bit worse than in the colder months. But the fact that days are brighter for longer makes a huge difference.

READ ALSO: How Switzerland’s largest cities are combating the heat

As light suppresses our body’s production of melatonin, the hormone that signals that it is time to sleep, the longer days irritate our internal clock, according to sleep experts.

The old tip of turning off your devices to avoid the blue light is also extra crucial. So around one hour before going to bed, you can start your “darkening” ritual throughout your home.

In that sense, it’s also better to avoid naps during the day to keep a better sleep routine.

Try to cool your room and yourself

Of course, the cooler temperatures are in your bedroom when you go to sleep, the better. You can help get temperatures a few degrees down by following these tips: keep the blinds and windows shut during the worst of the day and ventilate the cooler night breeze during the night.

Sleeping during a heatwave can be difficult. Photo: Yuris Alhumaydy / Unsplash

You can also moisten your curtains just before bedtime and leave the window open; the water evaporation will make it a bit cooler. If you can, another tip is to put your mattress on the floor as hot air rises – excellent advice for those sleeping on a bunk bed.

Don’t forget to turn off (and unplug!) electrical appliances, as those are heat sources.

READ ALSO: Eight great swimming spots to escape the Swiss summer heat

To cool yourself, you could take a lukewarm evening shower (not a hot one, those will make your body react by generating heat).

Fans and humidity help

As long as you’ve kept your room relatively cool, fans work. They help evaporate sweat which, in turn, helps your body regulate its temperature.

Putting a bowl of ice in front of the fan can also help cool the room.

Some people swear by dampening their sheets before going to bed. But if you’re not used to it, the feeling can be a little disconcerting. You can also place multiple ice containers in the corners of your room, which will melt slowly overnight and cool the air.

Why is it essential to have a good night’s sleep?

Several days of scorching temperatures can cause heat stress, according to the Swiss Tropical and Public Health Institute.

If the nights are not cool enough, the body can’t recover from the heat of the day, creating a dangerous condition called “thermal stress”, which can be fatal for the elderly and other vulnerable people.

While there are no statistics showing how many people have fallen victim to heat stress during the most recent heatwave, several cantons have implemented a system of home visits and frequent phone contact with this at-risk group.

READ MORE: How to keep your cool during Switzerland’s heatwave

SHOW COMMENTS