Swiss school closures cut Covid spread: new study
The Local - [email protected]
Published: 10 Jan, 2021 CET.
Updated: Sun 10 Jan 2021 15:22 CET
Switzerland's decision in the spring to shutter schools was one of the most effective measures in reducing mobility
and thus also transmission of Covid-19, a study showed on Sunday.
Researchers at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology in Zurich, ETH, determined that the closure of Swiss schools last March was responsible for cutting mobility by more than a fifth.
"School closures reduced mobility by 21.6 percent," Stefan Feuerriegel, an ETH professor of management information systems who headed the study, told AFP in an email.
"School closures reduce mobility, (which) then reduces new cases" of Covid-19, he said.
In a tweet, he said his team had analysed some 1.5 billion movements in Swiss telecommunication data between February 10 and April 26 last year to evaluate the impact on mobility as various anti-Covid measures were introduced.
*Nationwide* telecommunication data from SIM cards (aggregated & anonymized) predicts COVID-19 spread
?Analysis based on ~1.5 bn trips from Switzerland
?Mobility in March dropped by 49.1%
?1% lower mobility ➡️ 0.88-1.11% reduction in daily caseshttps://t.co/8hYRgDRnyE
— Stefan Feuerriegel (@stfeuerriegel) January 8, 2021
In decentralised Switzerland, its 26 cantons introduced measures at different paces before a country-wide partial lockdown, including school closures, was ordered on March 16.
Schools across the country remained closed for about two months before gradually opening up again.
READ ALSO:
-
Why are primary school students in Switzerland not required to wear masks?
-
Why are some parents in Switzerland ‘outraged’ about mask requirement in schools?
-
New Swiss studies cast doubts on theory children don't spread Covid-19
The study, which has yet to be peer-reviewed, found school closures ranked third in terms of reducing mobility.
At the top of the list was a ban on gatherings of more than five people, which was seen slashing mobility by 24.9 percent, and the closure of restaurants, bars and non-essential shops, which caused people to move about 22.3 percent less, the study shows.
Feuerriegel said it was not surprising that school closures had such a big impact on people's movements.
"If schools are closed, we can expect a large change in behaviour," he said, pointing out that "not only will kids stay home, but sometimes it also requires their parents to change their mobility as well."
School closures have been among the most controversial measures introduced around the world to help rein in the pandemic.
Children are far less likely to develop severe illness from Covid-19 than older people, but it remains unclear how much they transmit the virus.
The ETH study does not address that, but indicates that school closures can significantly reduce transmission by prompting people to move about and mingle less.
"Our analysis confirms school closure as a measure to slow the spread, through reduced mobility," Feuerriegel said.
Comments
See Also
Researchers at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology in Zurich, ETH, determined that the closure of Swiss schools last March was responsible for cutting mobility by more than a fifth.
"School closures reduced mobility by 21.6 percent," Stefan Feuerriegel, an ETH professor of management information systems who headed the study, told AFP in an email.
"School closures reduce mobility, (which) then reduces new cases" of Covid-19, he said.
In a tweet, he said his team had analysed some 1.5 billion movements in Swiss telecommunication data between February 10 and April 26 last year to evaluate the impact on mobility as various anti-Covid measures were introduced.
*Nationwide* telecommunication data from SIM cards (aggregated & anonymized) predicts COVID-19 spread
— Stefan Feuerriegel (@stfeuerriegel) January 8, 2021
?Analysis based on ~1.5 bn trips from Switzerland
?Mobility in March dropped by 49.1%
?1% lower mobility ➡️ 0.88-1.11% reduction in daily caseshttps://t.co/8hYRgDRnyE
In decentralised Switzerland, its 26 cantons introduced measures at different paces before a country-wide partial lockdown, including school closures, was ordered on March 16.
Schools across the country remained closed for about two months before gradually opening up again.
READ ALSO:
- Why are primary school students in Switzerland not required to wear masks?
- Why are some parents in Switzerland ‘outraged’ about mask requirement in schools?
- New Swiss studies cast doubts on theory children don't spread Covid-19
The study, which has yet to be peer-reviewed, found school closures ranked third in terms of reducing mobility.
At the top of the list was a ban on gatherings of more than five people, which was seen slashing mobility by 24.9 percent, and the closure of restaurants, bars and non-essential shops, which caused people to move about 22.3 percent less, the study shows.
Feuerriegel said it was not surprising that school closures had such a big impact on people's movements.
"If schools are closed, we can expect a large change in behaviour," he said, pointing out that "not only will kids stay home, but sometimes it also requires their parents to change their mobility as well."
School closures have been among the most controversial measures introduced around the world to help rein in the pandemic.
Children are far less likely to develop severe illness from Covid-19 than older people, but it remains unclear how much they transmit the virus.
The ETH study does not address that, but indicates that school closures can significantly reduce transmission by prompting people to move about and mingle less.
"Our analysis confirms school closure as a measure to slow the spread, through reduced mobility," Feuerriegel said.
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.