What to know about Switzerland's latest court judgement on assisted suicide
Switzerland's highest court this week ruled that patients with mental illnesses can be eligible for assisted suicide even without a psychiatric report.
What's happening?
The landmark decision was handed down on Wednesday by the Swiss Federal Supreme Court, reported Swiss broadcaster SRF.
The ruling involved a Swiss doctor called Erika Preisig, a doctor and assisted dying advocate based in the canton of Basel-Country, who was prosecuted in 2021 for assisting a mentally ill patient to die.
The prosecutor was of the opinion that Preisig had committed homicide because she had not obtained a psychiatric evaluation on the person before assisting the suicide.
Preisig was acquitted of charges of intentional homicide by the Federal Court, which dismissed the appeal by the public prosecutor's office of Basel-Country canton.
Preisig had previously been acquitted by the cantonal court, but the public prosecutor appealed the ruling and took the case to the Federal Supreme Court to urge for clarification.
What do previous rulings say?
In 2006, the Federal Supreme Court ruled that, in principle, it was permissible to assist a mentally ill person in committing suicide. But only if the wish to die is based on a well-considered decision by a person capable of making a judgement.
According to the highest judges in 2006, the wish to die must also not be an expression of a treatable mental disorder, and this must be clarified by a psychiatric report. Such a report was not available in the Preisig case.
What does it mean?
The Federal Supreme Court has clarified the situation: although Preisig had not obtained a psychiatric report, she had studied the medical records, had intensive discussions with the woman, questioned relatives and obtained a second opinion. The mentally ill woman was understood to have made a well-considered decision and was capable of judgement.
According to court documents, the woman had been suffering for several years and had undergone countless physical and psychiatric examinations.
The Federal Supreme Court confirmed that Preisig could assume, even without a psychiatric expert opinion, that the woman had a permanent wish to die, as she suffered from an incurable, permanent, severe mental impairment.
Federal judges believed all of this this was enough to justify the decision to help the patient to die.
With its judgment, federal judges have upheld Switzerland’s liberal law on assisted dying, as well as confirmed that a report from a psychiatrist is not always required to assist mentally ill people to die.
What is assisted suicide in Switzerland?
Switzerland’s assisted suicide laws allow people to take their own lives with the assistance of medical professionals.
It is a relatively unique scheme, with few other countries allowing the practice.
One important note to keep in mind is the difference between euthanasia and assisted suicide. Assisted suicide still requires the person in question to administer the suicide themselves, while euthanasia is where a doctor takes this final step.
Euthanasia is not allowed in Switzerland, while assisted suicide is allowed for both Swiss people and foreigners. Assisted suicide is legal in Switzerland on compassionate grounds.
Last year, the Swiss Academy of Medical Sciences laid out new guidelines for assisted suicide practices to be tightened in Switzerland.
READ ALSO: What are Switzerland's new assisted suicide rules?
These guidelines include a more stringent test for whether you should be allowed assisted suicide services, along with a longer waiting period and more meetings with doctors.
The main associations administering assisted suicides are Exit, Dignitas, Ex International, and lifecircle.
READ ALSO: How foreigners can access assisted suicide in Switzerland
Comments
See Also
What's happening?
The landmark decision was handed down on Wednesday by the Swiss Federal Supreme Court, reported Swiss broadcaster SRF.
The ruling involved a Swiss doctor called Erika Preisig, a doctor and assisted dying advocate based in the canton of Basel-Country, who was prosecuted in 2021 for assisting a mentally ill patient to die.
The prosecutor was of the opinion that Preisig had committed homicide because she had not obtained a psychiatric evaluation on the person before assisting the suicide.
Preisig was acquitted of charges of intentional homicide by the Federal Court, which dismissed the appeal by the public prosecutor's office of Basel-Country canton.
Preisig had previously been acquitted by the cantonal court, but the public prosecutor appealed the ruling and took the case to the Federal Supreme Court to urge for clarification.
What do previous rulings say?
In 2006, the Federal Supreme Court ruled that, in principle, it was permissible to assist a mentally ill person in committing suicide. But only if the wish to die is based on a well-considered decision by a person capable of making a judgement.
According to the highest judges in 2006, the wish to die must also not be an expression of a treatable mental disorder, and this must be clarified by a psychiatric report. Such a report was not available in the Preisig case.
What does it mean?
The Federal Supreme Court has clarified the situation: although Preisig had not obtained a psychiatric report, she had studied the medical records, had intensive discussions with the woman, questioned relatives and obtained a second opinion. The mentally ill woman was understood to have made a well-considered decision and was capable of judgement.
According to court documents, the woman had been suffering for several years and had undergone countless physical and psychiatric examinations.
The Federal Supreme Court confirmed that Preisig could assume, even without a psychiatric expert opinion, that the woman had a permanent wish to die, as she suffered from an incurable, permanent, severe mental impairment.
Federal judges believed all of this this was enough to justify the decision to help the patient to die.
With its judgment, federal judges have upheld Switzerland’s liberal law on assisted dying, as well as confirmed that a report from a psychiatrist is not always required to assist mentally ill people to die.
What is assisted suicide in Switzerland?
Switzerland’s assisted suicide laws allow people to take their own lives with the assistance of medical professionals.
It is a relatively unique scheme, with few other countries allowing the practice.
One important note to keep in mind is the difference between euthanasia and assisted suicide. Assisted suicide still requires the person in question to administer the suicide themselves, while euthanasia is where a doctor takes this final step.
Euthanasia is not allowed in Switzerland, while assisted suicide is allowed for both Swiss people and foreigners. Assisted suicide is legal in Switzerland on compassionate grounds.
Last year, the Swiss Academy of Medical Sciences laid out new guidelines for assisted suicide practices to be tightened in Switzerland.
READ ALSO: What are Switzerland's new assisted suicide rules?
These guidelines include a more stringent test for whether you should be allowed assisted suicide services, along with a longer waiting period and more meetings with doctors.
The main associations administering assisted suicides are Exit, Dignitas, Ex International, and lifecircle.
READ ALSO: How foreigners can access assisted suicide in Switzerland
Join the conversation in our comments section below. Share your own views and experience and if you have a question or suggestion for our journalists then email us at [email protected].
Please keep comments civil, constructive and on topic – and make sure to read our terms of use before getting involved.
Please log in here to leave a comment.