SHARE
COPY LINK
For members

CULTURE

‘The pleasure of punctuality’: Why are the Swiss so obsessed with being on time?

One of the first things a new arrival notices in Switzerland is how punctuality is a big part of local culture. Geneva-based Swiss-American journalist Helena Bachmann dives into the Swiss love affair with being on time.

'The pleasure of punctuality': Why are the Swiss so obsessed with being on time?
Always on time...Photo by Marius Mann on Pexels

From Swiss trains to Swiss watches, there are few Swiss stereotypes more ever present than punctuality. 

As the saying goes, “anyone who thinks the Germans are punctual has never been to Switzerland”.

And while plenty of stereotypes are just that, stereotypes, in this case the Swiss obsession with punctuality is painstakingly accurate. 

In 2019, an expansion of the Deutsche Bahn lines into Switzerland met some objection not because of the additional travel possibilities, but because the Swiss were concerned those tardy Germans would mess up their intricate transport systems. 

As noted by BBC Travel correspondent Eric Weiner, the Swiss not only want to be on time, but they take pleasure in being punctual. “The Swiss derive genuine joy from the fact that life unfolds on time and in a highly efficient manner.”

Exploring Switzerland’s love affair with punctuality

The first question that comes to mind is, why are the Swiss known for their punctuality?

Is it because they are so involved in watchmaking, or maybe they started manufacturing watches to encourage everyone to be on time?

What came first: the Swiss watch or punctuality? We won’t solve this chicken-or-the-egg conundrum right now, though it may be a story for another day.

Instead, let’s focus on the fact that punctuality is just how the Swiss tick. The often-repeated phrase here is “if you are on time, you are already late”.

Coming from the United States, the Swiss love for punctuality hit me as soon as I arrived – right on time, as it were. 

This is especially true when it comes to public transportation.

Earlier this year, I witnessed this scene: A bus pulls into a stop during the morning rush hour to take people to the train station.

About a dozen people come out from the bushes surrounding the stop. They know the bus is scheduled to arrive at 7:11 am, and it is already 7:10. They are Swiss and they have the bus timetable engraved in their brains.

As the bus starts to leave, a lone person runs after it, gesturing the driver to stop. The passengers look at him through the windows with pity: he must be a foreigner who made no effort to know the schedule by heart.

The bus continues on towards its next (punctual) stop and the lone person needs to make other plans. 

Admittedly, Switzerland is not the place for chronically tardy people.

Another scene, this time at the train station: The train is expected to arrive at 9:43 am and depart at 9:44. However, an announcement is made that the train will be four minutes late due to railway repair work somewhere in Switzerland.

This means it will arrive at 9:47 and leave at 9:48.

The announcement throws the entire platform full of people into disarray, as though a four-minute delay will change the entire course of their lives.

They start talking to each other in an animated manner, discussing the consequences of this tardiness and pondering “what has happened to Switzerland?”

The only people taking this news calmly are two women speaking Italian. Draw your own conclusions.

This is by no means an exaggeration – in 2014, the Swiss became aghast that their rail system was “failing” due to official reports that only 87.5 percent of the trains arrived within three minutes of their scheduled time, down from the government’s 89 percent target. 

Not only beautiful, but also on time. Photo by Fabrice COFFRINI / AFP
 

Why are Swiss wound tighter than other people when it comes to punctuality?

It is likely related to their desire to organise everything — actually, “micromanage” would be a better word — in the most efficient manner. In other words, they want everything to go according to plan and their lives to run like a (Swiss) clockwork.

Knowing what to expect, and when to expect it, seems to give them a sense of comfort.

Punctuality is also synonymous with discipline — another Swiss trait.

No wonder that Swiss who venture to less pedantic nations — for instance neighbours Italy and France, though Germany and Austria are more similar — are annoyed by the more relaxed attitude to timekeeping (and everything else, for that matter).

An American friend who has lived in Switzerland long enough to adopt some of the country’s persnickety ways, recounted how irritated she was when waiting for a train at Rome’s Termini station to take her to the airport.

She discovered that the timetable displayed two times: one the official departure and arrival, and the other the actual one. “Not just one train was delayed but all of them”, she said.

But let’s not forget one important thing…

Switzerland is a multi-lingual nation and each linguistic region has its own sub-culture, often influenced to a certain degree by their nearest neighbours.

Anecdotal evidence and my own experience show that people living in the German-speaking part are strictest when it comes to punctuality, while the Swiss-French are a tad more relaxed.

In the canton of Vaud, for example, the often-used expression, “quart d’heure vaudois” means that a slight delay is tolerated.

What about the Italian-speaking region? Common wisdom has it that “Ticino is like Italy, only cleaner”.

This expression can also be applied to timekeeping: “Ticino is like Italy, only more punctual”.

But not as punctual as Zürich.

Is punctuality… timeless?

Many people see rigorous punctuality as a thing of the past.

Young people especially are less pedantic about promptness than their elders, allowing themselves some leeway and flexibility on the spectrum of tardiness.

Does this mean Switzerland will get less punctual in the future? Only time will tell.
 
EXPLAINED: Why are cows so important in Switzerland?
 

Member comments

Log in here to leave a comment.
Become a Member to leave a comment.

LIVING IN SWITZERLAND

Do foreigners in Switzerland have the same legal rights as the Swiss ?

Foreigners living in Switzerland may be wondering what their basic rights are compared to Swiss citizens. The answer depends on several factors.

Do foreigners in Switzerland have the same legal rights as the Swiss ?

There are currently 2.2 million foreign nationals living in Switzerland — roughly 25 percent of the population.

Simply put, everyone residing in the country legally, regardless of nationality, has the same basic constitutional rights as Swiss citizens do — for instance, the right to human dignity, free expression, equality, protection against discrimination, and freedom of religion, among other rights.

They also have the right to fair and equitable treatment in the workplace, in terms of wages, work hours, and other employment-related matters.

As the law states, cantons and municipalities “shall create favourable regulatory conditions for equal opportunities and for the participation of the foreign population in public life”. 

If they are arrested or imprisoned, foreigners also have the right to fair trial and to the same treatment as their Swiss-citizen counterparts, including legal representation and due process of the law.

Even those who are subject to deportation have the right to be represented by a lawyer.

And the Swiss legal system doesn’t necessarily favour Swiss litigants over foreign ones. For instance, in some cases, foreign nationals whose request for naturalisation was denied but who then appealed the decision, eventually won.

The most recent example is a man in the canton of Schwyz whose application for citizenship was rejected due to a minor car accident, but a Swiss court overturned the decision, ordering that the man be naturalised this year.

READ MORE : Foreigner wins appeal after being denied Swiss citizenship due to car accident

Where the rights and privileges differ between foreigners and Swiss, as well as among foreigners themselves, is when it comes to work and residency rights.

 EU / EFTA nationals

People from these countries, who have B or C permanent residence status have sweeping rights in terms of residence, employment (including self-employment), and home ownership.

The only right that is denied them is the vote, though some cantons and communes grant their resident foreigners the right to vote on local issues and to elect local politicians. 

READ MORE : Where in Switzerland can foreigners vote?

Apart from the limit on political participation, EU / EFTA nationals can live in Switzerland in pretty much the same way as their Swiss counterparts.

There are, however, some groups of foreigners whose rights are curtailed by the Swiss government.

Third country nationals

They are people from countries outside Europe, for whom various restrictions are in place in terms of entry, employment and residency.

For instance, their “future employer must prove that there is no suitable person to fill the job vacancy from Switzerland or from an EU/EFTA state”, according to State Secretariat for Migration. This could be seen as a discrimination of sorts, but that’s what the law says.

Once employed, however, “their salary, social security contributions and the terms of employment must be in accordance with conditions customary to the region, the profession and the particular sector” — in other words, no discrimination is allowed.

Another area where non-European foreigners are disadvantaged in comparison with their EU / EFTA counterparts is home ownership. While third-nation B-permit holders can buy a property to live in (but not rent out), they can’t purchase a holiday or second home without a special permission.

To sum up, all foreigners in Switzerland, regardless of their status, are entitled to fundamental “human” rights, including freedom of speech and religion, and freedom from discrimination in life and employment.

They also have the right to legal protection and representation during litigation or other court actions.

However they don’t have the right to participate in the country’s political process and, depending on their status, have equal access to residency and employment.

SHOW COMMENTS